Land Surveyor Community Forum

Topcon versus TrimbleWhat are the differences between the following two types of GPS units?  I will be using both for RTK surveys without a base and the price difference is very significant.

1) Topcon Hiper SR Network Rover Kit (enabled with GGD 10Hz OaF files)

2) Trimble R10, internal 4110-470 Mhz radio

I have experience with the Trimble unit, but not with the Topcon.  Am I comparing apples to apples?

St. Paul, MN

You need to be a member of Land Surveyors United - Surveying Community & Forums to add thoughts!

Join Land Surveyors United - Surveying Community & Forums

Email me when people reply –

Replies

  • Apples to apples...yes, by design but not performance.  The Topcon SR can transmit via Bluetooth to another Receiver and act as a Base or a Rover.  The Trimble R10 has a Radio that does this (at a longer distance).  In short, you are comparing a really low-end GNSS receiver (Topcon) to a really high-end Receiver (Trimble).

    If I were you I would look into the Spectra Precision SP80.  This is a mid-range receiver, combining the best of Trimble, Ashtech and Spectra.  It works with Carlson and Spectra/TDS Survey Pro and receives all of the Constellations without any further upgrading in the future.  It has dual hot-swapable batteries and includes Z-Blade.  It also has an option for internal XDL Radios running a 2w.  The entire package will cost you half of the R10, around the same as the Topcon, but you'll be getting your money's worth.  

    Good luck to you.

    • I use a CHC 900+. Is that a Trimble type clone? It's works really well. Not any down time.

  • Hi,

    Do you know that there is a online product database where you can compare these products, read case studies, view brochures and read reviews. Maybe this can help!

    http://geo-matching.com/category/44/compare/1582,1808,2158

    http://geo-matching.com/category/id44-gnss-receivers.html?param=Y29...

  • Party Chief

    The short answer to your question is the Trimble is the latest released in the market. Has all the functionality that you can imagine, enclosed into one of the lightest weight units especially compared to what we are use to. Plus one of the big things is the xFill, which is like the navcom/john deere had in there units called RTK extend. It's when you would lose sats and normally go to a float solution the John  ]Deere sat called Starfire would pick up it's HD signal and keep you fixed for up to 15 mins. The specs show that Trimble is using the Omni Star sats to do the same thing. This technology was being promoted around 2004 by John Deere. Another strong point is the processors and the firmware features are as good as you can get these days....thats why it's more expensive. These units are built for global use  as well, where every kind of environment has been imagined. Now if you want to talk more specific about your area or projects you can call me  at 843.518.8488 Skip Farrow (this statement is not a sales pitch for Trimble or Topcon, it is from what I read from the specs).

    • Hi,

      I was told by the Trimble reps in Ireland that xfill works when the RTK correction signal is lost and not the rover receiver satellite fix signal loss. Is is not the case ?

      Co Down

This reply was deleted.

Help Us Preserve and Promote Land Surveying

Land Surveyor Community Forum

Most land surveying related topics are evergreen - meaning the topics of discussion are many times timeless.  If you have a question regarding Land Surveying in general, this is the place to ask your questions.    

Add Discussion

Find a Hub Forum to Post In

Forums for  Hubs for Land SurveyorsHowever, if you have a questions regarding a specific type of Land Surveying Equipment, Surveying Software, Land Surveying History or other topics related to land surveying, you will find that our Community Hubs all have dedicated forums.   Asking your questions inside these Hub Forums will ensure that you are asking a targeted audience of land surveyors who are following those topics.

Forums for Location Based Chapter Hubs for Land SurveyorsLikewise, you will find that all of our Location Based Chapter Hubs have dedicated forums for discussing land surveying topics related to specific locations around the world.  Asking your question inside the appropriate place inside the community will most likely get you the most feedback.   Enjoy!  We look forward to helping you solve your problem or expand your knowledge of land surveying.

Below are the categories for our general forum which spans entire global community.

Find Hubs Based on Location, Equipment or Type
Global Surveyor Map (members)

More from Land Surveyor Forum