Next Generation Land Surveyor Community

# UNCERTAINTY ON SURFACE/VOLUME CALCULATIONS

When I started my career, I have been attracted by one (of many) question : how accurate is the surface/volume calculations knowing the uncertainties of the points that define these geometrical figures. I really wanted to know in term of standard deviation what would be the "end results".

The solution was to propagate the variances (standard deviation squared) into the functional model (the mathematical formula in short) and to retrieve the results I was looking for.

By taking the formula to determine the surface of a polygon, we have the coordinates of all points.

By differentiating that equation vs point's coordinates, we can assimilate (at the first order) the derivates dx, dy to the standard deviation of course squared. The result was a pretty elegant formulation.

I will attach the development below.

Now having the standard deviation on the surface in function of the point's standard deviations ... we can reverse the approach and start from the customer's perspective.

For a given polygon, knowing the tolerance on the surface would be given ... what would be the standard deviation of the points we have to achieve. That's optimization ! No need to survey more accurately than needed for instance.

We can use the same rigorous approach for volume calculations.

What do you think ? Is that something you are also concerned with ?

Development :

Starting with the surface formula :

Then we can arrange the terms :

And proceed with differentiation :

Which leads to the final expression in term of standard deviation on the surface.

You will recognize that is the sum of the diagonal squared which can be formalized as a "surface" criterion like the GDOP is for GNSS position ! I think it's an elegant result ...

Now the step by step calculation :

This Content Originally Published by a land surveyor to Land Surveyors United Network

Views: 385

Communicate ⇣

Reply by Carlo Alberto Birocco on February 1, 2018 at 5:27pm

Hi Joel!

I appreciate your effort to evaluate with the statistics the "quality" of the model ... but IMHO is more important "number" and "location" of the points are describing the model.

I think that in our job (surveying) we rarely have the chance to evaluate a regular solid: more frequently we work with models (DTM)

Few (but also many ...!) badly distributed points (although accurated ...) can not build a good model.

I think a "dense" survey with rtk (centimeter accuracy) data is more than adequate for most of the volume calculations that are required for excavations or quarries.

Your method is very suitable for industrial applications: I'll keep this! Thanks

Reply by Paul Williams on February 1, 2018 at 2:18pm
This just gives me brain freeze!
The question is why do you want to?... I mean isn't it a standard to always get more information as accurately as you can rather than what is required. I've no idea how I get a position out of the instrument... By that I mean the electronics used to measure angles and distance.. It just works and for that I'm grateful because chains and rods were a pain in the ass! Ha ha ha ha

Where Thousands of Professional Land Surveyors, Students of Surveying and Educators are United through Collaborative Knowledge and Purpose.

## Tools,Apps and Quick Guides

DEDICATED TO THE MEMORY OF SKIP FARROW (1953-2015)

Help With Survey Equipment

#### Social Support For Equipment

Surveying Video Categories

Surveying Photo Categories

United States Hub Forums

 AK AL AR AZ CA CO CT DE FL GA HI IA ID IL IN KS KY LA MA MD ME MI MN MO MS MT NC ND NE NH NJ NM NV NY OH OK OR PA RI SC SD TN TX UT VA VT WA WI WV WY

International Surveyor Hub Forums

Resources for Company Owners

Land Surveyor Social Media

Surveyor Resources Collections

### Leica iCON robot 50 Robotic Total Station iCR55 w/ Leica CC80 tablet controller

 \$16,499.00End Date: Sunday Dec-9-2018 14:59:03 PSTBuy It Now for only: \$16,499.00Buy It Now | Add to watch list

### Trimble S8 DR PLUS 2" Robotic Total Station w/ Prism & Charger, Case 2.4Ghz

 \$18,499.00End Date: Sunday Dec-9-2018 14:46:19 PSTBuy It Now for only: \$18,499.00Buy It Now | Add to watch list

### Spectra TS415 Total Station Transit with Case Battery Charger & Data Cable

 \$1,699.99End Date: Saturday Dec-8-2018 9:41:42 PSTBuy It Now for only: \$1,699.99Buy It Now | Add to watch list

### LEICA TC407 Total Station Dual DisplayTransit Level w/ Battery, Charger and Case

 \$1,931.99End Date: Thursday Nov-29-2018 6:04:08 PSTBuy It Now for only: \$1,931.99Buy It Now | Add to watch list

### Leica TCR403 Reflectorless Total Station Dual Display Transit Level

 \$2,599.99End Date: Thursday Nov-29-2018 6:01:43 PSTBuy It Now for only: \$2,599.99Buy It Now | Add to watch list