Community Hub Information

Land Surveying Ethics

Land Surveying Ethics is a discussion forum for issues involving ethics in the practice of Land Surveying.  Every Land Surveyor has faced or will face an ethical problem or concern.  This is where we air it out and compare notes.  What is or is not ethical is sometimes a matter of law, sometimes a matter of opinion, but always a matter of morality.

Geolocation: #Earth
Members: 77
Latest Activity: Jun 7

Morality and Ethics

Morality and ethics

Ethics (also known as moral philosophy) is that branch of philosophy which addresses questions about morality. The word 'ethics' is commonly used interchangeably with 'morality' and sometimes it is used more narrowly to mean the moral principles of a particular tradition, group, or individual. Likewise, certain types of ethical theories, especially deontological ethics, sometimes distinguish between 'ethics' and 'morals': Although the morality of people and their ethics amounts to the same thing, there is a usage that restricts morality to systems such as that of Kant, based on notions such as duty, obligation, and principles of conduct, reserving ethics for the more Aristotelian approach to practical reasoning, based on the notion of a virtue, and generally avoiding the separation of 'moral' considerations from other practical considerations.

Source: wikipedia.org

Latest Discussions By Category ▿

Proportioning, Profit, and other PLSS Problems

Started by Scott D. Warner, PLS Aug 7, 2013. 0 Replies

It is, indeed, my opinion that proportioning a PLSS section of land to restore the original location of the corner post should be the last resort. Unfortunately, and likely, in my opinion, that it be…Read more →

Find Similar Content by Clicking These Tags ☟
Subject Tags: land surveying profitability, land surveying ethics, how much does a survey cost, land surveyor, usplss

Land Survey = Insurance

Started by Scott D. Warner, PLS. Last reply by DAVID C. GARCELON Apr 1, 2013. 5 Replies

If a land survey were to be construed as an insurance policy on…Read more →

Find Similar Content by Clicking These Tags ☟
Subject Tags: title, ,, survey, , land, , alta, ALTA, "

Handling an ethical dilemma

Started by Scott D. Warner, PLS. Last reply by Scott D. Warner, PLS Dec 20, 2012. 9 Replies

Have you ever encountered an ethical dilemma?  If so, how did you handle it?…Read more →

Find Similar Content by Clicking These Tags ☟
Subject Tags: surveyor, land surveyor, surveying ethics, ethos, ethics

Professional Ethics - What Are They and Why Are They Important?

Started by David Bosshard, RLS. Last reply by Matt Harnett Dec 17, 2012. 2 Replies

This file is a pdf of a presentation delivered by John Matonich, PS at the 2012 Wisconsin Society of Land Surveyors Annual Institute.  Posted by permission.Read more →

Find Similar Content by Clicking These Tags ☟
Subject Tags: surveying, Land, Surveyors, Professional, Ethics

Leave a Comment

Say Something ⇣

Comments Welcome!   Sign in or register.

Reply by Scott D. Warner, PLS on March 26, 2013 at 8:45pm

David C. Garcelon presents a very interesting set of questions related to ethics.  I have added my responses.

"Is Land Surveying ethics different than Civil Engineering ethics? ...or Political Ethics?"  The ethical professional, notwithstanding specialization, categorization, departmentalization, compartmentalization, or any other "ization", except realization, will conduct business in an ethical manner, and without prejudice.  As far as the oxymoron of political ethics is concerned, I do not consider politicians to be professionals, only public servants.  

"Can we separate out Ethics, Morality, Legality, Diplomacy, Professionalism, Decency, etc. from each other?"  We can make an attempt at pulling apart a matrix of interconnected doctrines and human behaviors, dissecting the very nature of the whole, but how difficult that must be.

"When a potential client asks us to survey their property lines and provide them with a plan..BUT..they do not want the plan recorded, how should we respond?"  In most jurisdictions, failure to record, file, or otherwise make express notice of the results of a land survey constitutes professional misconduct, however, land planning does not constitute land surveying.

"When we think "the law is a ass" as Bumberry said in Charles Dickens novel, do we tell the client and use it as an excuse to ignore the law?"  "The law can not be ignored, and the ethical professional should not be ignorant of the law.

"When we find what we think is an error by another surveyor do we tell our client, the board of registration, or the surveyor?"  In my professional opinion, the ethical course of action would be to first contact the surveyor as a professional courtesy, allowing the surveyor to correct or debunk that which may or may not be an error in the first place.  I do not believe that approaching a client without first consulting the originator of the apparent error is ethical behavior.  If another surveyor is, in fact, in error, and consistently and chronically in error, perhaps the board of registration should be petitioned for an investigation, but only as a last resort.

I look forward to reading other opinions.

Scott D. Warner, R.L.S.

Reply by DAVID C. GARCELON on March 26, 2013 at 5:06pm

Scott,

Land Surveying ethics is a great subject to discuss!

Is Land Surveying ethics different than Civil Engineering ethics? ...or Political Ethics?

Can we separate out Ethics, Morality, Legality, Diplomacy, Professionalism, Decency, etc. from each other?

When a potential client asks us to survey their property lines and provide them with a plan..BUT..they do not want the plan recorded, how should we respond?

When we think "the law is a ass" as Bumberry said in Charles Dickens novel, do we tell the client and use it as an excuse to ignore the law?

When we find what we think is an error by another surveyor do we tell our client, the board of registration, or the surveyor?

I hope you generate a lot of discussion with this forum!

David C. Garcelon

 

Members (77)

 
 
 

Land Surveyors Celebrate the Past Present and Future of Professional Land Surveying in this Geosocial Network. Frictionless GeoCollaboration

Surveyor Hubs and Tags

Help Keep Us Alive and Free!

Surveyor Community Hubs For World Regions

Surveying Hubs For US States

Social Support For Equipment

Surveying Photos by Tag

Surveying Videos by Tag

What You Missed

Profile IconJosh Frazer, Brad Martin, Gerald Bernhard and 2 more joined Land Surveyors United
1 hour ago
Jansen Loi added a discussion to the group Microsurvey Support Group
Land Survey Media Thumbnail

Starnet Help

Hi,I am currently using starnet V6 and I am having a problem. Tried searching through the manuals…See More
1 hour ago
Jansen Loi joined LSU Justin's group
Land Survey Media Thumbnail

Microsurvey Support Group

Microsurvey Support group is for  MicroSurvey users in the field and office. This group is for…See More
1 hour ago
charlie-jm commented on Thiago Paim's photo
Land Survey Media Thumbnail

Brazil Surveying in VW

"es total station by topcon "
8 hours ago
kenneth foong joined Malik Abdur Rehman's group
Land Survey Media Thumbnail

Excel Spreadsheets for Surveyors

This group is for discussions related to the use of spreadsheets and excel in land surveying.See More
16 hours ago
kenneth foong replied to Durai Kannan's discussion STAR NET PROCESSING in the group Excel Spreadsheets for Surveyors
"You can try use this FRT to covert start net format."
16 hours ago
Mike McCulley promoted LSU Justin's group Topcon Support Group
yesterday
Desmond Elliott updated their profile
yesterday
Profile Iconkenneth foong, Brian Loucks, kayveen murithi and 3 more joined Land Surveyors United
yesterday
Achilles Nizamopoulos replied to Achilles Nizamopoulos's discussion survce localization problem
"Hello Desmond, thanks for the reply. i am tryin gto follow tour steps. how do you procces the RINEX…"
yesterday
Surveying Jobber's video was featured

Precision and Accuracy in Geodetic Surveying

This brief video, produced in collaboration between NOAA’s National Geodetic Survey and The COMET Program, is aimed at surveying professionals, planners, policy-makers and others who use mapping products. The video emphasizes that survey…
yesterday
Gennady's 2 photos were featured
yesterday
ePalmetto shared their page on Tweet This
yesterday
Jacquelin RAMAROLAHY's discussion was featured

SOFTWARE with NAVCOM SF2050M

Hi all,Did you already have any experience with this device? which software is fit better to read…See More
yesterday
LSU Justin shared Charles Carpenter's discussion on Tweet This
yesterday
Gennady was featured
yesterday
Julius's photo was featured

Camel Crew

"collecting assumed X,Y,Z on disturbed borehole (geophysical survey point) inside camel cage"
Thursday
ePalmetto promoted Julius's photo
Thursday
ePalmetto shared Julius's photo on Tweet This
Thursday
Brian Loucks joined LSU Justin's group
Land Survey Media Thumbnail

California Land Surveyors

California Land Surveyors group is a discussion forum for land surveyors who live and survey in the…See More
Thursday

Take This Page With You

follow us in feedly

Take this Page With You

QR Code for This Page: What is this?

Surveyor Goodies

© 2014   © Created by Land Surveyors United

Badges  |  Contact LSU  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service

Related Posts for Land Surveyors UnitedRelated Posts Plugin for Land Surveyors United Network ForumRelated Surveying Photos Land Surveyors United Live Support