My company(Consultant) transferred me to a new project a 4 TOWERS consisting of 34 floors and linked in pairs from the top. The piles and shoring system works were carried out by 95%. When reviewing the Control Points of the project, I found that they used the Scale Factor in the implementation.

Note that

* Dimensions of the building are 100 * 100 meters.

* Tolerance is 7 cm in pile.  
the question
- Is it possible to complete the building with a Scale Factor?

- Or any one have another solution?

This Content Originally Published by a land surveyor to Land Surveyors United Network

Views: 550

See Your Saved Posts Timeline

☇ Reply to this

Replies to This Discussion

You hold an L.S. License and you can’t answer your own question?! Pathetic!!!

Easy there... 

Dear Singer 

I mentioned in my higher words that this is not my fault and i know how to solve, otherwise should be canceled my License. 

I know it is impossible to use the Scale Factor in the building, but i liked to share this issue with all of us. 

thanks for your reply. 

Kevin Singer, you have an LS and would dare to trash a fellow surveyor because he’s asked his extended community for advice or information? You should be ashamed of yourself sir! Just for future reference that kind of comment or attitude towards a fellow member will not be tolerated.

Dear Anthony Whitlock

Thanks and highly appreciated you.

Mohamad,

A bit more information would be useful - 1) when you say a scale factor was used on the control points, are you referring to the general site survey?  2) When you say 95% do you mean that the piling and shoring work is 95% complete?

With out this information I will say the following - A scale factor is used mostly in larger area or route surveys - think a couple of kilometers or miles.  Once you get to a building layout condition revert back to a scale factor of 1.00000 - remember architects only think in square, level and plumb (I know..don't start)  I've never applied a scale factor to a building before. And I am only speaking about normal conditions - nothing like Burj Khalifa or Ping An towers.

On the tolerance vs. the size of the building, consider this - a 100.00 meter length must be established with a tolerance of +/- 7 cm or 0.07 meters at each end. So your +/- or long and short for the 100 meters is 14 cm or 1 part in 1428.  Normal survey scale factors come into play in the 1 part in 10000 and higher ranges.  So your construction tolerances seems far greater ( read "looser" here ) than any survey related scale factor that you might have on your control points.

Hope this helps and Good Luck,

Kevin

Kev,

Easy there? On me?

I know nothing of your background; nor you, mine.

A wee fair tiny bit of my surveying – background, that is –  is that I have done virtually every bit (type/discipline/genre … pick your flavor) of surveying around this planet for nearly three decades.

I have far, far, far too often witnessed – firsthand – the absolute incompetence and sheer inability of *surveyors* from India, Pakistan, Afghanistan, Sri Lanka, etc. They are wholly incapable of surveying anything. They exist in the business solely by nepotism – quite typically in its purest form of being religion-based.

Harsh? Without doubt.

As harsh they are, my words as equally true.

Every bit of sincere,

Kevin Singer

Dear Kevin Singer 

i have 14 years experience 9 as a consultant.
you get the main point who did this issue is Pakistan surveyors ( consultant and contractor) and this first time to me to meet them, most of the data requested from them they brought it  wrong.

 

thanks for your reply. 

Mohamed

Dear Kevin D. Allen

1) when you say a scale factor was used on the control points, are you referring to the general site survey? yes 

2) When you say 95% do you mean that the piling and shoring work is 95% complete? yes and i completed up to 100%  by the same sequence, and thin the correction will be at the whole site.

With out this information I will say the following - A scale factor is used mostly in larger area or route surveys  - think a couple of kilometers or miles.  Once you get to a building layout condition revert back to a scale factor of 1.00000 - remember architects only think in square, level and plumb (I know..don't start)  I've never applied a scale factor to a building before. And I am only speaking about normal conditions - nothing like Burj Khalifa or Ping An towers.

( In accordance with US specifications, the Scale Factor should be eliminated in areas less than 250000 square meter, my project area 18500 m sq) and I know it is impossible to complete the building with Scale Factor, and this issue need to coordinate with the Arch. and Civil. 

On the tolerance vs. the size of the building, consider this - a 100.00 meter length must be established with a tolerance of +/- 7 cm or 0.07 meters (sorry the +/- 7 cm tolerance in pilling only not in the whole of building) . So your +/- or long and short for the 100 meters is 14 cm or 1 part in 1428. (the Scale Factor which used is 0.999666 which mean the variance in 100.00 m distance will be 0.0334 m)  Normal survey scale factors come into play in the 1 part in 10000 and higher ranges.  So your construction tolerances seems far greater ( read "looser" here ) than any survey related scale factor that you might have on your control points.

I offer you my sincere greetings and thank you for your patience in responding and for the excellent information you mentioned.
I met this problem and I liked to share it with all.
After i processed it I will mention here everything that has been done, and i like any advise from any one.

Mohamed

First of all, you don't need a scale factor in a building stake out because the architectural dimensions are as they are. If they used a gps in coordinating the controls , then a scale factor of 1-0.99 can be used in correcting distances, but not the building. Thank you.

Dear Kweku Danquah 

the Scale Factor which used in the project is 0.999666,  it is impossible to complete the building with Scale Factor, and i will correct and after correction i will raise what i did.

i appreciate you for  your reply 

Mohamed

More information would be nice but I think I understand your question with the info you have provided. Keep in mind that I am in the United States and therefore do not us the Metric System typically. That being said, I believe your question is in regards to the actual established survey control of the project. If there is a scale factor noted on the control sheet from the engineering plan set then I would imagine that the original design survey was done using GPS on a State Plane Coordinate System that was scaled to ground coordinates. When you get to the field and are occupying a control point you will need to use the published scale factor in order to check into your other control points. Once you have checked into the other control and everything is working as it should, the first thing I would do is shoot the existing piles and bolt patterns. If something isn’t right between the control you are using and the proposed design plans of the building you will see it then and there. If the pilings are positioned as they should be and your control is checking accurately, you should be good to go. Keep in mind that now that the pilings are laid out, they basically control more so than the project control points (so long as the civil engineer and the architect agree that they are ok with the position of the existing piling). Sorry if I haven’t helped or if you already knew everything I stated, I was trying to answer your questions without a complete understanding of the situation you are facing.

RSS

Where Thousands of Professional Land Surveyors, Students of Surveying and Educators are United through Collaborative Knowledge and Purpose.

Tools,Apps and Quick Guides

DEDICATED TO THE MEMORY OF SKIP FARROW (1953-2015)


Help With Survey Equipment

Social Support For Equipment

Surveying Video Categories

Surveying Photo Categories

United States Hub Forums

International Surveyor Hub Forums

Resources for Company Owners

Land Surveyor Social Media

Surveyor Resources Collections

Getting Started & Newsletter

New Equipment Added Daily

Trimble Nomad GPS GNSS Robotics Total Station Data Collector w/ Survey Pro

$535.00
End Date: Thursday Nov-15-2018 7:54:55 PST
Buy It Now for only: $535.00
Buy It Now | Add to watch list

AdirPro GNSS Surveying 220-Degree Wide Angle Prism 720-21 for Topcon and Sokkia

$599.95
End Date: Wednesday Nov-14-2018 14:14:07 PST
Buy It Now for only: $599.95
Buy It Now | Add to watch list

SOKKIA TOTAL STATION SET530R3 SET5F SET5E SDR33 SURVEY STATION, TDS RECON KARA

$7,500.00
End Date: Wednesday Nov-14-2018 13:54:21 PST
Buy It Now for only: $7,500.00
Buy It Now | Add to watch list

Nikon total station DTM 332.

$1,200.00
End Date: Saturday Nov-10-2018 14:48:32 PST
Buy It Now for only: $1,200.00
Buy It Now | Add to watch list

Nikon Dtm-520 Total Station Surveying Instrument SKU 6694

$216.50 (19 Bids)
End Date: Thursday Oct-18-2018 6:32:34 PDT
Bid now | Add to watch list

Surveyor Birthdays

Surveyor Birthdays Today

Surveyor Birthdays Tomorrow

© 2018   © Created by Land Surveyors United   Powered by

Badges  |  Contact LSU  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service