I've got an old Trimble GPS setup - a classic Zephyr Geodetic, Trimark III, 5700 base with a 5800 rover.  I'm pretty much just using it for grading and building/utility location as we slowly build out our campus master plan.  Lately I've been spraying grading boundaries and shape lines for a couple excavators we have working on a detention basin on campus.

I usually set up on an unknown point and calibrate the site to 2 known points (one mag nail in rock and one gin spike in pavement), using just one for vertical datum.  I get what I think are good results.  I measure HI (which I don't believe matters when set up on an unknown, unmarked point), I watch my rod height and each time out I finish with a check in to a tack and hub that I set several months ago.  Yet, having been out there 5 times now I've literally gotten 5 different elevations at that hub, varying by up to 0.30'.  Horizontal seems to be consistently accurate.  I'm not using a GEOID or SPC, but just set no datum at 1.000 correction.  Fortunately, for hammering a giant hole in solid rock, a few tenths here and there won't matter, but certainly will if I want to set curb form later.

Any ideas what I might be missing, how I could pinpoint the problem or possibilities of old instrument errors?

Mahalo, LSU, for all your knowledge and community service.

- Dave

This Content Originally Published by a land surveyor to Land Surveyors United Network

Views: 396

See Your Saved Posts Timeline

☇ Reply to this

Replies to This Discussion

Dear Mr. Drahn,

I see from your profile that you are in Hawai'i, which is built upon a group of volcanic oceanic islands. It has significant variations in topography and therefore one assumes, the geoid undulates significantly there.

If you use the same pole and antenna throughout your project (as you run it now) the pole height is probably insignificant. It is so because you are NOT measuring differences of elevation. You are getting 3D positions relative to the center of the Earth Fixed Earth Centered Cartesian system. This is simply plane geometry in 3D., X, Y, Z.

Elevations are not relative to this simple system. Especially in mountainous areas, the gravitational potential varies greatly from place to place. Elevations are relative to a standard gravitational potential (zero elevation such as NAVD88).Additionally, GPS does not "know" which way is up since it works globally. However, it gives good horizontal results because we are usually surrounded by satellites E-W and N-S but NOT up-down. So the local vertical data has usually 2-3 times the doubt in it compared to the horizontal.

To properly determine the elevations one needs to know where the ground's surface is, not where the antenna is. Then the geoid height must be included to get an orthometric height (or elevation). 

I bleve the geoid model has recently been extended to Hawai'i but I have no experience using it. Where it covers CONUS variations of doubt may be as large as 4-8cm..

With all that said, if the area of your work is small most of that may be ignored. I do have a rule I've always followed. GPS is good enough for most vertical work but not for "hard stuff" like road surfaces, weirs, sewers, and curbs.

Best wishes,

JAC 

You can do accurate (first order)vertical measurements with GPS but it requires multiple bases and at least two periods  separated by a four hour window.

Occupy the known hub and tack that you previously set from now on, apply the appropriate GEOID Model for your location, calibrate to the two monuments that you have been all along, take a check shot on another known point and go from there.  There is absolutely no reason to be setting up on unknown locations when you have good relative coordinates for your project.    I would expect to see up to about a tenth of vertical fluctuation throughout the course of a project but three tenths is very high and indicates you are not using correct procedures.  Try the above steps and it should help you throw out allot of your existing errors.  PS, always take an antenna height, the corrections you are receiving from your base station basically control the elevations that your rover will shoot.  If you set up your base station with a half a foot bust in the antenna height, all of your shots you take with the rover will have the same half a foot error.  

One can perform extremely accurate observations with GPS provided long occupations and repeated redundant observations. Indeed, the basis for the adjustment of the most recent realization of NAD83 is based on the CORS. Again, the results will be ellipsoid or ECEF values, not elevations.

No matter how long nor how accurate the GPS results are, in order to derive elevations or orthometric heights from them requires the application of the geoid model with its inherent doubt. Good enough for dirt work.

JAC

Dave,

 You sound like you are working in an old school RTK-GPS environment.  So I'll give you some old and dusty RTK-GPS tips that kept me out of trouble... for the most part that is - lol

1) When you are establishing a local frame of reference, always remember YOU are the datum for the project like this.  So I would never use only 2 points for several reasons.  Basic plane geometry for one - 3 points fix your datum plane and with a 4th you can see some basic residual error.  I never - ever - trusted a one point calibration on any but the smallest of sites when collecting data or staking out with GPS 

2) J. Cavell is spot on with his comment on inherant vertical error.  Even the newest GPS gear has double the vertical error vs. horizontal.  A 20mm +/- vertical tolerance means that its possible to have vertical variations on the same point of up to 40mm (0.13 ft) just from the equipment.  Start adding in the real world errors and your 0.30' is easy to obtain.  

3) Your 5 different elevation reading can best be explained by the differences in the different SV's (space vehicles or satellites)  orbits, Pdop values, number of Sv's all come into play.  Because you are most likely reading 5 to 7 SV's at a time ( GPS only ) you have fewer redundant checks in your data to correct your postions.

4) Update the ephemoris data in your equipment - yup thats old school but the equipment you described is pre GPS/GLANOSS and by todays GPS standards, kind of primative.  So manual data maintence is needed. 

One final note - and I agree with J. Cavell - you are scraping dirt so 2 or 3 tenths here and there isn't the end of the world, but keep an eye on it because you are rubbing the upper error limits of what should be allowed.

Hope this helps

Kevin 

Great info.  Thanks, Kevin.  When you say "update the ephemeris", is that through checking that I'm using the latest firmware? Manually altering dat or job files?  Or something else?

SV orbit data - some of the older GPS gear had to load the orbit data or "tracks" of the SV's.  Just like if you took a star shot, you have to have the correct date and time to apply your angle reading to the star.  use the wrong day and you can be a long way off.   So check your manual for the 5700/5800 - you can find them online - and see if they do it automaticly or if you have to manually do it.  My old GPS gear - circa 1997 - would take a few minutes when turned on to update itself.  Just not sure for your equipment

I believe our 5800 is a single frequency receiver, so you are not getting the redundancy from using two bands like most of the modern GPS.  This will also contribute to your error.

Whenever I used GPS, I always check two or three known points from the very beginning. Then I'd go from there. 

Thanks, all.  It sounds like I'll need to spend a little more setup time to (maybe) get more consistent results.  Good info.

The instrument height should always measured accurately while setting up the base.

If your site is small enough, you could put monuments (beacons) in around the perimeter of the site, and some spread out inside the site as check points. Use precise leveling to determine orthometric heights for all, then use the perimeter points to calibrate for geoidal tilt and separation, check the calibration against the internal check points. The calibration will however only be good if your GPS observations are good (longer observations and good satellite geometry) and you don't have the instrument errors mentioned elsewhere in this discussion. If your GPS elevations (after adoption of calibration) agree well with the orthometric heights of all internal check points, you should have confidence in the elevations of new points within the calibration area. Always work from a known point using the saved calibration and always check on other points. Do not work outside of your calibration area. We have always used this method before adoption of geoid models, but keep in mind geoid undulation versus distance.

RSS

Where Thousands of Professional Land Surveyors, Students of Surveying and Educators are United through Collaborative Knowledge and Purpose.

Dedicated to the Memory of Skip Farrow (1953-2015)

+ Surveyor Sharer

Drag Button to bookmark bar and view submitted links here.Will soon be moved to a directory

AFGHANISTAN SURVEYORS ALBANIA SURVEYORS ALGERIA SURVEYORS AMERICAN SAMOA SURVEYORS ANDORRA SURVEYORS
ANGOLA SURVEYORS ANGUILLA SURVEYORS ANTIGUA & BARBUDA SURVEYORS ARGENTINA SURVEYORS ARMENIA SURVEYORS
ARUBA SURVEYORS AUSTRALIA SURVEYORS AUSTRIA SURVEYORS AZERBAIJAN SURVEYORS BAHAMAS SURVEYORS
BAHRAIN SURVEYORS BANGLADESH SURVEYORS BARBADOS SURVEYORS BELARUS SURVEYORS BELGIUM SURVEYORS
BELIZE SURVEYORS BENIN SURVEYORS BERMUDA SURVEYORS BHUTAN SURVEYORS BOLIVIA SURVEYORS
BOSNIA & HERZEGOWINA SURVEYORS BOTSWANA SURVEYORS BRAZIL SURVEYORS BRITISH INDIAN OCEAN TERRITORY SURVEYORS
BRUNEI DARUSSALAM SURVEYORS BULGARIA SURVEYORS BURKINA FASO SURVEYORS BURUNDI SURVEYORS CAMBODIA SURVEYORS
CAMEROON SURVEYORS CANADA SURVEYORS CAPE VERDE SURVEYORS CAYMAN ISLANDS SURVEYORS CENTRAL AFRICAN REPUBLIC SURVEYORS
CHAD SURVEYORS CHILE SURVEYORS CHINA SURVEYORS COLOMBIA SURVEYORS COMOROS SURVEYORS
CONGO SURVEYORS DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC OF THE CONGO SURVEYORS COOK ISLANDS SURVEYORS COSTA RICA SURVEYORS COTE D'IVOIRE SURVEYORS
CROATIA SURVEYORS CUBA SURVEYORS CURACAO SURVEYORS CYPRUS SURVEYORS CZECH REPUBLIC SURVEYORS
DENMARK SURVEYORS DJIBOUTI SURVEYORS DOMINICA SURVEYORS DOMINICAN REPUBLIC SURVEYORS ECUADOR SURVEYORS
EGYPT SURVEYORS EL SALVADOR SURVEYORS EQUATORIAL GUINEA SURVEYORS ERITREA SURVEYORS ESTONIA SURVEYORS
ETHIOPIA SURVEYORS EUROPEAN UNION SURVEYORS FAROE ISLANDS SURVEYORS FIJI SURVEYORS FINLAND SURVEYORS
FRANCE SURVEYORS FRENCH GUIANA SURVEYORS FRENCH POLYNESIA SURVEYORS GABON SURVEYORS GAMBIA SURVEYORS
GEORGIA SURVEYORS GERMANY SURVEYORS GHANA SURVEYORS GIBRALTAR SURVEYORS GREECE SURVEYORS
GREENLAND SURVEYORS GRENADA SURVEYORS GUADELOUPE SURVEYORS GUAM SURVEYORS GUATEMALA SURVEYORS
GUERNSEY SURVEYORS GUINEA SURVEYORS GUINEA-BISSAU SURVEYORS GUYANA SURVEYORS HAITI SURVEYORS
HOLY SEE SURVEYORS HONDURAS SURVEYORS HONG KONG SURVEYORS HUNGARY SURVEYORS ICELAND SURVEYORS
INDIA SURVEYORS INDONESIA SURVEYORS IRAN SURVEYORS IRAQ SURVEYORS IRELAND SURVEYORS
ISLE OF MAN SURVEYORS ISRAEL SURVEYORS ITALY SURVEYORS JAMAICA SURVEYORS JAPAN SURVEYORS
JERSEY SURVEYORS JORDAN SURVEYORS KAZAKHSTAN SURVEYORS KENYA SURVEYORS KIRIBATI SURVEYORS
KOREA SURVEYORS KOREA REPUBLIC OF SURVEYORS KUWAIT SURVEYORS KYRGYZSTAN SURVEYORS LAO PEOPLE'S DEMOCRATIC REPUBLIC SURVEYORS
LATVIA SURVEYORS LEBANON SURVEYORS LESOTHO SURVEYORS LIBERIA SURVEYORS LIBYAN ARAB JAMAHIRIYA SURVEYORS
LIECHTENSTEIN SURVEYORS LITHUANIA SURVEYORS LUXEMBOURG SURVEYORS MACAU SURVEYORS MACEDONIA SURVEYORS
MADAGASCAR SURVEYORS MALAWI SURVEYORS MALAYSIA SURVEYORS MALDIVES SURVEYORS MALI SURVEYORS
MALTA SURVEYORS MARSHALL ISLANDS SURVEYORS MARTINIQUE SURVEYORS MAURITANIA SURVEYORS MAURITIUS SURVEYORS
MAYOTTE SURVEYORS MEXICO SURVEYORS MICRONESIA SURVEYORS MOLDOVA SURVEYORS MONACO SURVEYORS
MONGOLIA SURVEYORS MONTENEGRO SURVEYORS MONTSERRAT SURVEYORS MOROCCO SURVEYORS MOZAMBIQUE SURVEYORS
MYANMAR SURVEYORS NAMIBIA SURVEYORS NAURU SURVEYORS NEPAL SURVEYORS NETHERLANDS SURVEYORS
NEW CALEDONIA SURVEYORS NEW ZEALAND SURVEYORS NICARAGUA SURVEYORS NIGER SURVEYORS NIGERIA SURVEYORS
NIUE SURVEYORS NON-SPEC ASIA PAS LOCATION SURVEYORS NORFOLK ISLAND SURVEYORS NORTHERN MARIANA ISLANDS SURVEYORS NORWAY SURVEYORS
OMAN SURVEYORS PAKISTAN SURVEYORS PALAU SURVEYORS PALESTINIAN TERRITORY OCCUPIED SURVEYORS PANAMA SURVEYORS
PAPUA NEW GUINEA SURVEYORS PARAGUAY SURVEYORS PERU SURVEYORS PHILIPPINES SURVEYORS POLAND SURVEYORS
PORTUGAL SURVEYORS PUERTO RICO SURVEYORS QATAR SURVEYORS RESERVED SURVEYORS REUNION SURVEYORS
ROMANIA SURVEYORS RUSSIAN FEDERATION SURVEYORS RWANDA SURVEYORS SAINT KITTS & NEVIS SURVEYORS SAINT LUCIA SURVEYORS
SAINT MARTIN SURVEYORS SAINT VINCENT & THE GRENADINES SURVEYORS SAMOA SURVEYORS SAN MARINO SURVEYORS SAO TOME & PRINCIPE SURVEYORS
SAUDI ARABIA SURVEYORS SENEGAL SURVEYORS SERBIA SURVEYORS SEYCHELLES SURVEYORS SIERRA LEONE SURVEYORS
SINGAPORE SURVEYORS SINT MAARTEN SURVEYORS SLOVAKIA (SLOVAK REPUBLIC) SURVEYORS SLOVENIA SURVEYORS SOLOMON ISLANDS SURVEYORS
SOMALIA SURVEYORS SOUTH AFRICA SURVEYORS SOUTH SUDAN SURVEYORS SPAIN SURVEYORS SRI LANKA SURVEYORS
ST. PIERRE AND MIQUELON SURVEYORS SUDAN SURVEYORS SURINAME SURVEYORS SWAZILAND SURVEYORS SWEDEN SURVEYORS
SWITZERLAND SURVEYORS SYRIAN ARAB REPUBLIC SURVEYORS TAIWAN; REPUBLIC OF CHINA (ROC) SURVEYORS TAJIKISTAN SURVEYORS TANZANIA UNITED REPUBLIC OF SURVEYORS
THAILAND SURVEYORS TIMOR-LESTE SURVEYORS TOGO SURVEYORS TOKELAU SURVEYORS TONGA SURVEYORS
TRINIDAD AND TOBAGO SURVEYORS TUNISIA SURVEYORS TURKEY SURVEYORS TURKMENISTAN SURVEYORS TURKS AND CAICOS ISLANDS SURVEYORS
TUVALU SURVEYORS UGANDA SURVEYORS UKRAINE SURVEYORS UNITED ARAB EMIRATES SURVEYORS UNITED KINGDOM SURVEYORS
UNITED STATES SURVEYORS URUGUAY SURVEYORS UZBEKISTAN SURVEYORS VANUATU SURVEYORS VENEZUELA SURVEYORS
VIET NAM SURVEYORS VIRGIN ISLANDS (BRITISH) SURVEYORS VIRGIN ISLANDS (U.S.) SURVEYORS WALLIS AND FUTUNA ISLANDS SURVEYORS YEMEN SURVEYORS
ZAMBIA SURVEYORS ZIMBABWE SURVEYORS SURVEYORS

Location Based Surveying Practices

Land Surveyors United is the world's FIRST Global Social Network for geospatial professionals. We have dedicated, geolocated support groups for practically every country, continent and state on earth, for you to utilize for building your personal network. We are all essentially concerned with the same issues, no matter where we are located on earth. However, surveying practices and methods vary depending on the geographic location where we work. If you have noticed similarities and differences between the conditions, laws and practices between two or more areas of the world,discuss it in this forum. Build your reputation online by posting relevant discussions in your local group below.

Join and Introduce Yourself in Your Local Geosocial Forum:

Alabama Alaska Arizona Arkansas California
Colorado Connecticut Delaware Florida Georgia
Hawaii Idaho Illinois Indiana Iowa
Kansas Kentucky Louisiana Maine Maryland
Massachusetts Michigan Minnesota Mississippi Missouri
Montana Nebraska Nevada New Hampshire New Jersey
New Mexico New York North Carolina North Dakota Ohio
Oklahoma Oregon Pennsylvania Rhode Island South Carolina
South Dakota Tennessee Texas Utah Vermont
Virginia Washington West Virginia Wisconsin Wyoming

Not based in the US? Here are other groups for surveyors around the world to join and contribute knowledge and experiences as a land surveyor:

Africa Asia Australia Europe Russia Canada
Antarctica S.America N. America India Malaysia Caribbean

And more... Find your group forum based on location.

Choose Your Equipment Group Here

Handheld US Social Support for Land SurveyorsNIKON Social Support for Land SurveyorsTrimble Social Support for Land SurveyorsTopcon Social Support for Land SurveyorsSokkia Social Support for Land SurveyorsAshtech Social Support for Land SurveyorsNAVCOM Social Support for Land SurveyorsMagellan Social Support for Land SurveyorsLeica Social Support for Land SurveyorsAltus Positioning Social Support for Land SurveyorsMicroSurvey Social Support for Land SurveyorsJuniper Systems Social Support for Land SurveyorsTraverse PC Social Support for Land SurveyorsCarlson Software Social Support for Land Surveyors

what where  
job title, keywords or company
city, state or zip jobs by job search

PLEASE DONATE TODAY. Your generosity preserves surveying and mapping knowledge for future generations. Thank you.

Survey Equipment Troubles?

Geo Visitors Map

Choose Your Group Here

Surveying Equipment Support for Leica, Carlson, Sokkia, Trimble, Topcon, Altus, Nikon equipment


© 2017   © Created by Land Surveyors United   Powered by

Badges  |  Contact LSU  |  Privacy Policy  |  Terms of Service

Live Support